What’s your recipe?

by | Jul 1, 2022 | Cocktails, Intellectual Property | 154 comments

Back when I lived in New Orleans[2] my friends and I would periodically go forth to seek out the perfect margarita recipe. This was before the Internet so the main problem was avoiding the dinosaurs roaming the streets. We never did settle on one but to be honest settling on one wasn’t the point.

Last year I was motivated to try again. What a difference a meteor and a few million years makes! The streets are safe but now there’s no reason to go outside. I fired up my computer, entered “margarita” into DDG, opened up a clean spreadsheet, and started filling out ingredient columns. I thought that with enough data I’d be able to discern a pattern and derive the fundamental truth.

Immediately I noticed a pattern: sugar. No wonder people are saying they like these recipes. One drink could fuel a marathon! I decided to do some original historical research and found this obscure article:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Margarita

Which says the original recipe doesn’t include sugar. One claimant is:

2 parts tequila
1 part triple-sec
1 part lime juice

I bought premium ingredients, brought them to last year’s birthday party, and mixed up a pitcher. My guests were very polite. They liked the concoction so much they insisted on letting me have almost all of it.[3]

Clearly something has changed since circa 1940 when legends of the date of the invention of the margarita clump. Maybe people were stronger back then or maybe because everyone smoked heavily their taste buds were all shot and they needed their drinks to be able to dissolve iron.

I gave up on originalism and, consulting my spreadsheet, tried this combination:

2 parts tequila
1 part triple-sec
2 parts lime juice
1 part orange juice

Simple to remember and no sugar added![4] It’s still a strong drink by the standards of my neighborhood, both alcohol and citrus, but when poured over a glass of ice and with salt[5] I think it’s excellent. I’ve had many positive[6] comments about how it’s not too sweet.

What’s your recipe?

Footnotes:

[1] Alas, the only thing still young about me is my self-image.

[2] Now I live in Vermont. In a previous article I mentioned the problem of tractor trailer trucks getting stuck in Smuggler’s Notch. It just happened again:

https://newportdispatch.com/2022/06/28/truck-gets-stuck-in-smugglers-notch/

[3] I admit it took a while to finish.

[4] OK, cheap triple-sec contains vast tracts of sugar. But I didn’t add it.

[5] Salt or no salt? Flame war!

[6] Almost always with a request for a refill so I don’t think they were just being polite.

About The Author

Richard

Richard

154 Comments

  1. Count Potato

    I usually added a dash of Rose’s lime juice. Sugar? Definitely if it’s frozen. Salt? Yes.

    • Count Potato

      I got in the Rose’s habit because many bars use sour mix or lime mix. Both have sugar, but lack lime flavor.

  2. rhywun

    I think I’ve blacked out on tequila before so I tend to avoid it now.

    • Richard

      rhywun! I too have a duplicate serial number start note. The serial number starts with 068.

      • MikeS

        I told a buddy at work about star notes 5-ish years ago. He got so in to it he now has a few dozen. All captured in the wild.

      • Richard

        I too only have a few dozen. Tell him about the duplicate serial number thing.

      • MikeS

        What do you mean “duplicate serial number”?

      • Richard

        In 2016 the literal money printer accidentally produced two sets of one dollar bills with duplicate serial numbers. All star notes. A matched pair in excellent condition recently sold for $15K.

      • MikeS

        Oh shit! Did not know about that. Haven’t been keeping up on my numismatic news. Gotta tell my friend about this.

      • rhywun

        What does the star mean?

        @Richard – mine starts with 038

        Weirdly, most of my bills are NOT New York B’s.
        They were when I was younger.

      • MikeS

        It denotes that it is a replacement note for bills that were damaged in the printing process.

        Which makes it an even bigger f’up that they’d reprint them.

      • rhywun

        Ah, huh.

        I have a small hoard of about forty singles, only two with a star. This one and another one from Dallas.

      • Richard

        Star notes are those that have a star after the serial number instead of a letter. They’re printed to be replacements for when regularly printed notes are botched. Finding a star note in circulation is like how finding an S mint mark penny used to be.

        I have maybe a dozen star note ones and one star note five after years of looking.

      • rhywun

        how finding an S mint mark penny used to be

        I was a child coin nerd so I remember this well.

      • The Hyperbole

        I had a star note one in my wallet the other night but it didn’t have the other criteria you guys were talking about so I left it in there, I apparently have since spent it.

      • Richard

        Your loss. Circulated star notes have a market value of one dollar.

    • MikeS

      You think?

      • rhywun

        Well, that’s what they told me.

    • J. Frank Parnell

      Ha. I had a bad experience with “tequila” in my younger days. and for years just the smell of it would make me sick.

      But then I realized it was just Cuervo, not real tequila.

  3. EvilSheldon

    Were you possibly inspired by my old forum post? Fortunately, I’ve regained by missing ability to make margaritas, and have been enjoying a few lately.

    4 parts tequila Blanco (I’m liking Casamigos these days – it adds a very faint coconut accent to the finished cocktail.)
    3 parts Cointreau
    2 parts fresh lime juice

    Shake over ice. Salt is optional.

    • Richard

      Dinosaurs remember, because I don’t recall your post. I’ve been pondering this one for a few years so I hope it was some time ago.

  4. Richard

    I sent my recipe to one of my olde N.O. friends who was aghast at the orange juice. I hadn’t heard of OJ in margaritas before either moving to Vermont but it seems perfectly symmetrical to the triple-sec to me.

  5. MikeS

    I think the problem is too many people expect a margarita to taste like a daquiri.

    • EvilSheldon

      Ayo. They’re both good, but should taste very different.

  6. Tundra

    Tequila, soda and lime juice is one of my go-tos if the place only has the sugary shit.

    What’s your favorite tequila for your recipe?

    • Richard

      This is embarrassing. Literally whatever’s cheapest. Olde may I be but my purpose in drinking alcohol hasn’t changed at all.

      • Tundra

        Not embarrassing at all. Tequila snobs are even more ridiculous than wine, beer or bourbon snobs.

        It’s a buzz delivery medium – drink whatever you like!

      • R.J.

        Agreed. Doesn’t have to be pricey to taste good!

      • dontreadonme

        One time in Mexico I struck up convo with some filthy rich expat who was drinking tequila ordered by the resort just for him. He shared a good portion of the bottle with me probably because he was completely bewitched by my fiancΓ©. Long story short, it rivaled any of the best scotch I have ever had and completely destroyed my opinion of tequila as just cheap booze made from ‘cactus’.

      • The Bearded Hobbit

        We used to bring back a tequila from Mexico called Centinario. As you say, it was as good as a fine Scotch. I called it “sippin’ tequila” because, like a fine whisky, you took little nips rather than slam a shot with salt and lime.

  7. R C Dean

    3 oz. Tequila
    1 oz Salerno Blood Orange Liqueur
    3/4 oz lime juice
    1/2 oz agave nectar

    You’re welcome.

    • Richard

      I had to ask my town’s[1] liquor store to stock lime juice. Really.[2] I can’t imagine what the reaction would be if I asked them to stock agave nectar.

      Footnotes:

      [1] Imagine the smallest concentration of people you’d think of as a town. No, it’s not that big.

      [1] I’m using “really” here because I think I’m wearing out “literally”.

      • Sensei

        Legit LOL

      • MikeS

        If your town has a liquor store, it’s not that small. The entire county I grew up in doesn’t have a liquor store; gotta get your off-sale at one of the seven bars.

      • Richard

        My town’s liquor store is mostly a gas station. Until the late stupidness it also had a good selection of ammo.

      • The Bearded Hobbit

        There are (or were: they’ve mostly gone defunct) small towns in New Mexico that consist only of a bar. The bar in Llaves, NM, was only open during hunting season.

      • UnCivilServant

        I was starting to think you grew up in a dry county until you mentioned the bars.

        Did your county even have a town?

      • MikeS

        Nine towns; county population around 3,000.

      • slumbrew

        I’ve got this recipe for artisanale lime juice you should try. Way better than the store bought stuff.

      • Chafed

        WTF is artisanal lime juice?

      • Spudalicious

        Fresh squeezed?

      • MikeS

        Zoom is waiting for you.

      • slumbrew

        This guy gets it.

      • Chafed

        Like artisanal s-. You know what? Never mind.

  8. DEG

    Alas, the only thing still young about me is my self-image.

    I have that problem too.

    Yes, I know there are older people than me here.

  9. The Bearded Hobbit

    Try Midori instead of lime juice.

    • UnCivilServant

      Yes.

      I’m mostly annoyed because the final rulings will only apply to the various circuits since no merits ruling came from SCOTUS. So we’ll have to re-litigate all of them locally.

      • Richard

        If I didn’t think it was actually the other way around, I’d think the Supreme Court was acting like a consultant and creating opportunities for subsequent work.

      • Rebel Scum

        Tbf “the right of the people…shall not be infringed” leaves a lot of wiggle room in our federalist system. ///jk

    • Chafed

      I didn’t know that happened. I hope CA’s 10 round limit for magazines gets tossed. That will make it a lot easier (and possibly cheaper) to buy a pistol.

  10. UnCivilServant

    OT – I hate it when I find the actual term for an object or feature, but know that if I use it, most readers won’t recognize the word and it doesn’t help paint the mental picture for the story.

    It’s a Prang, but how many people would draw Ankor Wat from the term?

    • The Bearded Hobbit

      Stephen R. Donaldson didn’t have that problem. Just about once per paragraph I was reaching for a dictionary.

      • UnCivilServant

        There are times when that works, but when painting a picture with words, making the reader break away from the paragraph disrupts the imagery.

      • rhywun

        All you have to do is fat-finger the word to define it.

        /what’s a paperback?

    • Gender Traitor

      If I read “Prang,” I’d think “pretty colors.” It would paint a mental picture (and then I’d probably go buy some to paint a literal picture,) but not necessarily the picture you had in mind.

  11. Drake

    I’m fine with the original. My lazy easy shortcut is using some Simply Limeade. The sugar in the limeade is enough to sweeten it up a little.

  12. Rebel Scum

    1) Grab beer.
    2) Open beer.
    3) Consume beer.

    Alternatively…

    1) Grab wine.
    2) Open wine.
    3) Pour wine.
    4) Consume wine.

    Chill/ice as desired.

  13. Richard

    I’m outside on my Adirondack chair. Guess what I’m drinking? A patch of rain went north leaving my sky with big fluffy clouds that turned bright orange as the sun set. I’m wearing permeation-infused clothes so the bug aren’t bothering me except they are crawling around the computer’s screen. Shit. I’m getting maudlin.

    • R.J.

      I am making a rum punch. Orange and Pineapple juice, Rose’s grenadine, dark and white Bacardi Rum. Nice and cheap. Delicious in heat.

      • Richard

        One of my family’s heirlooms is my grandfather’s liquor recipe book. My brother has it so I can’t quote the details but it’s clear what my GF’s favorite punch was. It’s like:

        – a bottle of this liqueur
        – a bottle of that liqueur
        – a bottle of champagne
        – an entire fresh pineapple

        We’d like to make it up here in north nowhere Vermont but the fresh pineapple requirement is difficult.

      • R.J.

        Delicious!

      • J. Frank Parnell

        Hey, if your girlfriend wants you to consume pineapple, you should consume pineapple.

      • Chafed

        That’s a new euphemism.

      • J. Frank Parnell

        That’s not a euphemism, it’s actual advice.

      • Name's BEAM. James BEAM.

        There are supplements that help. I’ve tried one, years ago. Reports from the field (ahem) were favourable, but the supplements (made from fruit extracts, mostly) weren’t cheap.

      • Chafed

        More than $20 (same as downtown.)?

      • Name's BEAM. James BEAM.

        Yes, unfortunately. Otherwise I’d still be using them.

        I s’pose I could roll my own, but that would involve quite a bit of R&D (not the fun kind, though I’m sure that would come into play at some later point…).

  14. Rebel Scum

    Neighbors are already doing fireworks in these parts. Should be a fun weekend.

    • Richard

      No fireworks so far this evening but I am watching fireflies.

    • rhywun

      I can see a pretty big display out my living room window – it’s over either the nearby golf course or the VA center or the army fort.

    • Gender Traitor

      Fireworks are competing with thunder here in SW OH. I’m rooting for thunder.

  15. Rebel Scum

    Not guilty.

    As a successful entrepreneur and heiress, Savannah Daisley was used to the high life – but this week, everything changed.

    Police allege the North Shore woman had sex with a 14-year-old child on four occasions last year, and on Tuesday this week, she faced Waverley Court after being charged with four counts of aggravated sexual intercourse with a child between 14 and 16 years old.

    Ms Daisley, who was refused bail, has strenuously denied the allegations and intends to plead not guilty.

    • slumbrew

      Covered that yesterday, I think.

      Feels kinda weird to charge someone where the victim will be furiously masturbating to the memory for the next decade or so.

      • Sensei

        It does, but if you reverse the sexes it points to an interesting double standard.

      • slumbrew

        Assuredly

    • creech

      Why does someone who looks like her need to boink a 14 y.o.? Half the men in Oz would jump at the chance for a jump.

      • slumbrew

        Perhaps she really is innocent?

        Who knows. People be crazy.

      • R C Dean

        Or, she didn’t.

  16. db

    I use:

    the juice of 1.5 limes
    1-1/8 oz triple sec
    2 oz tequila (plata)
    splash of Grand Marnier to taste
    over rocks

  17. Richard

    Ladies (hypothetical) and gentlemen, both my computer and my cell phone hotspot are running out of power. I look forward to reading any subsequent discussion tomorrow after the clouds have cleared and I can recharge.

  18. Spudalicious

    2 parts tequila
    1 part triple-sec
    1 part lime juice

    Simple as that. It’s called a margarita. But I don’t drink them. I prefer a fine glass of tequila, and a Pacifico back.

  19. Gustave Lytton

    Back when I lived in New Orleans[2] my friends and I would periodically go forth to seek out the perfect margarita recipe.

    This is like looking for the best Tom & Jerry in Waikiki.

    • Name's BEAM. James BEAM.

      Blue Hawai’i, but otherwise, yeah.

  20. creech

    It’s happened again in the Philly burbs: another road rage incident with a shooting death. Latest case: little old Vietnamese immigrant driving “too slow” during rush hour. Passenger in the offended driver’s vehicle, jumps out of car at the next stop and unloads on the car, killing the driver’s husband. This is maybe the third time I remember this kind of road rage leading to a killing in this area. What are the shooters thinking when they do this? : “It’s worth 25 years in prison to ‘show him?'” Give the person the finger or shout, but shoot? Someone cut you off, or is in your lane, or gave you the finger first. Why is that worth their life, and yours???

    • rhywun

      25 years in prison is not enough for a cold-blooded murder like that.

    • The Bearded Hobbit

      A few years back there was an incident where some guy cut off some other guy to get to an exit. Other guy opened fire on the offending car and killed a six year-old girl.

      That’ll show ’em!

    • Chafed

      I don’t believe they are thinking. They are childishly reacting. If what I’m reading about Krassner is true, they don’t much to fear by behaving this way.

  21. Mojeaux

    Sorry about that abrupt leave-taking. The subject of my gossip unexpectedly came to our temporary abode.

  22. Yusef drives a Kia

    My recipe? Romanian breakfast,
    Coffee and cigarettes
    /then Beer

    • J. Frank Parnell

      Romanian breakfast

      Blood of a virgin?

      • Chafed

        Pie’s blood pudding?

      • thrakkorzog

        Vlad’s hat?

    • PieInTheSky

      I never heard that refered to as romanian, maybe slav breakfast

      • Name's BEAM. James BEAM.

        Definitely French, particularly in the Midi.

  23. CPRM

    I’m all alone in the Zoom room. It’s dark and scary πŸ™

    • Chafed

      Don’t start Toobin.

  24. Name's BEAM. James BEAM.

    Most tequila is shite. Most mezcal is shite.

    But Bacanora? Elixir of the gods. Which is why it’s almost impossible to find.

    Only to be sipped straight and neat.

  25. PieInTheSky

    margarita is a low class drink. I would not touch it.

  26. PieInTheSky

    There ia something weird about bucharest airport. No lines anywhere while.most of europe has huge delays in airports. I passed security and passport control in like 3 minute total. Took me 22 minutes from leaving home to getting to the gate.

    • PieInTheSky

      If in an airport, is it socially acceptable to drink a beer at 7 AM?

      • CPRM

        That’s acceptable everywhere but in a church. Then you drink wine.

      • Name's BEAM. James BEAM.

        Yes. And any other alcohol.

        But stay classy β€” order some breakfast, too.

      • Chafed

        In some places, it’s required.

      • rhywun

        Yes. Airports are not subject to any time etiquette.

      • Name's BEAM. James BEAM.

        Well, they are, but if there’s any place on Earth where the phrase β€œIt’s always five o’clock somewhere in the British Empire” has any meaning, it’s an airport.

      • Gustave Lytton

        What is tine etiquette? I used to work graves. I’d have a beer with my before sleep meal (“breakfast”).

      • PieInTheSky

        Graverobbing without a beer after is questionable anyway

      • MikeS

        Abby Normal.

    • rhywun

      LOL

      • Chafed

        How is your B5 watching going?

      • rhywun

        On S02E07.

    • rhywun

      Ridiculous. God she is so fucking stupid. I should say they – they all push this stuff. Who’s going to tell her that criminals don’t apply for gun permits?

      • Tulip

        They know that. The point is to make you comply.

      • Fourscore

        My goodness, don’t they know they have to have permit to own a gun? Otherwise robbery is against the law and the criminal could get in trouble.

    • Shpip

      What are the odds that a federal judge in NY will actually enjoin the newly-passed statutes as soon as a lawsuit is filed?

  27. Not Adahn

    Daily Quordle 159
    7️⃣4️⃣
    5️⃣3️⃣
    quordle.com
    🟨🟨⬜⬜⬜ ⬜🟨⬜🟨⬜
    ⬜⬜⬜⬜🟨 ⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜
    ⬜🟨⬜🟨⬜ ⬜🟨⬜🟨🟨
    ⬜⬜⬜🟨🟨 🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩
    ⬜⬜🟩⬜⬜ ⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛
    🟨🟨🟩🟨⬜ ⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛
    🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩 ⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛

    ⬜⬜⬜⬜🟩 ⬜🟩⬜🟨⬜
    ⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜ ⬜⬜🟩⬜⬜
    ⬜⬜⬜🟩⬜ 🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩
    ⬜🟩⬜⬜🟨 ⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛
    🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩 ⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛

    • SDF-7

      Another wonderful, wonderful Quordle chump day. Oy.

      Daily Quordle 159
      8️⃣7️⃣
      πŸŸ₯3️⃣
      quordle.com
      🟩⬜⬜⬜⬜ 🟨⬜⬜🟨⬜
      🟩⬜🟨🟨⬜ 🟨⬜⬜🟨🟨
      ⬜🟨⬜🟨⬜ ⬜🟨⬜🟨🟨
      ⬜⬜⬜🟨⬜ ⬜⬜🟨🟨⬜
      🟩⬜🟩🟩⬜ 🟨🟨⬜⬜⬜
      ⬜⬜🟩⬜⬜ ⬜🟩🟨⬜⬜
      ⬜⬜⬜🟨🟨 🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩
      🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩 ⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛

      ⬜⬜⬜🟨⬜ 🟨🟨⬜⬜⬜
      ⬜⬜⬜🟩⬜ 🟨🟨⬜🟩🟩
      ⬜⬜⬜🟩⬜ 🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩
      ⬜⬜🟨🟩⬜ ⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛
      ⬜🟨🟩⬜⬜ ⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛
      ⬜🟩🟩🟩🟩 ⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛
      ⬜🟩⬜⬜🟨 ⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛
      ⬜⬜🟩⬜⬜ ⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛
      ⬜🟩🟩🟩🟩 ⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛

  28. Not Adahn

    I have no idea if the club I’m visiting cancels matches on account of rain. I guess I’ll find out.

  29. Tres Cool

    suh’ fam
    whats goody yo

  30. Tres Cool

    Reading briefly about margaritas made me think of Mexico.
    That made me think of this:

    What do you call a 5-man gay mariachi band?

    Juan Direction

  31. Gender Traitor

    Good morning, homey, NA, SDF-7, 4(20), Tulip, and rhy! It’s a bit cloudy here at Tranquility Base this morning after last night’s rain, but not unpleasant. At 71 degrees ‘Murcan, it’s already a trifle too warm for my Dragons hoodie.

    This week we noticed that one of the neighbor’s outdoor cats, a long-haired black cat named Lucifer, has taken a liking to napping on TB’s futon, particularly in the late afternoon and early evening. This morning when I came outside, he was standing by the far corner of the futon and skittered away. (He’s a shy guy.) He’d obviously been on the futon since last night – I’d come out to take off the wearing-away nail polish strips from my last manicure and had swept off the futon – because there was a little circle of dust and debris at his accustomed spot, luckily on the far side of the futon from where I sit. He is, after all, essentially a fuzzy black Swiffer with ears. (Note to self: suggest to his humans that they rename him LuSwiffer.)

    • Lackadaisical

      Good morning GT

      • Gender Traitor

        Good morning, Lack! πŸ˜ƒ

  32. Ownbestenemy

    I am taking 82 degrees with 85% humidity over 100+ of ‘dry heat at the moment. So far North Carolina has been nice. We trek down to S.C. today. Met some really nice folks in a small town we just found after we turned off GPS and drove last night.

    • Gender Traitor

      Safe and happy travels! πŸ›£πŸš™

      • Ownbestenemy

        Thank you!

    • slumbrew

      Nice. My brother is in Apex,NC and there’s a lot to like down there.

  33. Sean

    Mornin Glibs.

    • Gender Traitor

      Good morning, Sean! πŸ‘πŸΌπŸ‘πŸΌ

      • Sean

        πŸ˜‰

    • Fourscore

      Morning folks,

      Another beautiful day in the woods. The mosquitoes have let up a lot, some still available. My bee partner is supposed to show up today, hopefully we’ll see some positive results today. Lots of flowers now.

      • Sean

        πŸ³β˜•πŸ

    • hayeksplosives

      Morning

  34. Spartacus

    My recipe is
    1 part Cointreau
    2 parts tequila
    4 parts mixer.

    I usually splurge for a good mixer, and often throw in an extra dash of tequila.
    For mixed drinks, I usually go with El Padrino anejo. I used to keep a bottle of don julio 1942 for sipping but that shit got way overpriced ($160 if you can find it) so now I use casa noble anejo.

  35. Tulip

    Daily Quordle 159
    6️⃣8️⃣
    7️⃣5️⃣
    quordle.com

  36. trshmnstr the terrible

    I just finished up teaching the kiddo to ride a two wheeler. It took about 10 minutes. Three passes with me holding the seat to varying degrees, and she was good to go. She has been riding a balance bike for a couple months, and I think that massive accelerated the process.