The Beer Wars: An Incomplete History of the American Beer Industry (pt 4)

by | Apr 25, 2023 | Beer, Brewing, History | 104 comments

Part 1

Part 2

Part 3

When we last left off we were entering the 1970s and we were two weeks from flattening the curve.  (Reading comments on Part 3 while prepping this were depressing.  The good news is we were all right.)

I will start by repeating a chart from the previous article:

Top 10 U.S. Brewers. Year: 1970

RANK BREWER BARRELAGE
1 Anheuser-Busch, Inc. 22,201,811
2 Jos. Schlitz Brewing Co. 15,129,000
3 Pabst Brewing Co. 10,517,000
4 Adolph Coors Co. 7,277,076
5 F & M Schaefer Brewing Co. 5,749,000
6 Falstaff Brewing Corp. 5,386,133
7 Miller Brewing Co. 5,150,000
8 Carling Brewing Co. 4,819,000
9 Theo. Hamm Brewing Co. 4,470,000
10 Associated Brewing Co. 3,750,000

Total Barrelage Of All U.S. Brewers in 1970: 121,861,000 barrels.
Top 10 Brewers’ Percentage of Total U.S. Barrelage: 69 percent.

The Beer Wars this series was created to discussed lasted from roughly 1975 through 1995.  Both end points are vague at best.  In some ways it was just a continuation of the consolidation that was covered in part 3.  But, more so that in the past, this was fought on the airwaves.  Commercial advertising would make or break the winners.  And it wasn’t at all clear who those would be.

Schaeffer was one of the breweries that grew by buying up regional breweries.  In 1972, they opened a new plant in Allentown, PA.  It originally had a capacity of 1.1MM barrels.  They expanded it to 2.5MM in 1974 and to 5MM in 1975.  With this, they closed most of their smaller breweries.  They were out of the top 10 by 1980 and in 1981, they would sell out to Stroh (see 1980 chart below).  Their Allentown brewery would be bought by Diageo (Smirnoff Ice was produced there) and then later sold to Sam Adams in 2008.

Carling would also fall out of the top 10 by 1980 due to Canadian reasons.  They eventually merge with Molson in 1989.

 

Hamm was acquiring by Heublein in 1965.  In 1973, it was sold to a group of Hamm’s distributors, which seems to violate lots of stuff from part 2.  In 1975, Olympia (see below again) would buy them.  Of course, Pabst would have to get involved, because, Pabst eventually owns or is owned by everyone in the beer industry.  In 1983, Pabst buys Olympia and trades Hamm’s St Paul brewery to Stroh.  It closed in 1997 after a 137 year run.  Hamm’s is still produced today by Molson Coors, but that is a few episodes down the line.

Associated Brewing was exactly what it sounded like, a merger of many smaller regional breweries that were struggling.  By 1972, they were done.  Heileman (see below) bought their assets from bankruptcy.

 

 

 

 

Top 10 U.S. Brewers. Year: 1980

RANK BREWER BARRELAGE
1 Anheuser-Busch, Inc. 50,200,000
2 Miller Brewing Co. 37,300,000
3 Pabst Brewing Co. 15,091,000
4 Jos. Schlitz Brewing Co. 14,900,000
5 Adolph Coors Co. 13,800,000
6 G. Heileman Brewing Co. 13,270,000
7 Stroh Brewery Co. 6,161,255
8 Olympia Brewing Co. 6,091,000
9 Falstaff Brewing Co. 3,901,000
10 C. Schmidt & Sons 3,625,000

 

Total Barrelage Of All U.S. Brewers in 1980: 176,311,699 barrels.
Top 10 Brewers’ Percentage of Total U.S. Barrelage: 93 percent.

 

And we reach 1980.  You can see the consolidation that has happened.  The top 10 has gone from 69% of the market to 93%.  A-B has more than doubled in ten years.  Miller has gone up 7 fold.  You have to be big and have a big advertising budget to compete.

What else was going on in the 70s?  Lite beer.  We mentioned Gablinger trying it in the late 60s, but Miller made it work.  Meister Brau in Chicago created Meister Brau Lite from the Gablinger recipe, then sold out to Miller in bankruptcy in 1972.  “Less Filling.  Tastes Great” was the result.

Everything was fizzy and yellow by now.  The beer world was almost all the same.  But there was one bright spot.  Fritz Maytag (yes, from that family) bought Anchor Brewery in the 1960s.  He reformulated Anchor Steam and in 1975 Anchor Liberty Ale was released.  It was a hoppy pale ale.  Maybe, just maybe, there was hope.

And as in other parts, I have to cover what was happening to Falls City in this time frame.  The answer is “a lot”.  In 1975, they would be the first brewery to use Sta-Tab openers instead of pop tops.  In 1977, they would create Billy Beer for Billy Carter.  It was licensed to three other regional breweries so that it could be sold nationally.  It was a quick fad, and production stopped in 1978.  Also in 1978, Falls City would post its first ever financial losses.  It would cease production and sold out to Heileman.  It would eventually be owned by Pittsburg Brewing.  For a while, Iron City and Falls City were identical beers, put in separate cans.  After Pittsburg’s bankruptcy, the name returned home and is a small craft brewery in Louisville.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U5APOrMribc

 

 

And some music, that wouldn’t seem to be on topic, but kind of is.

About The Author

robc

robc

I like beer.

104 Comments

  1. Brochettaward

    Today, I saw something that triggered me to such an extent that even now I can barely contain my hurt and anger. I saw a car with a bumper sticker that said Third Is First. I was nearly brought to tears from my anguish. My people have suffered so much. Suffered tremendously for all that is The First. My entire body shook with rage and indignation. The only thing I could think to do is to respond with violence. Such extreme violence that no one will ever make the mistake of saying these hateful words aloud again. That windshield is no more, cracked into a million pieces. I stood over the destruction and my emotions fully burst. The tears flowed. I knew that I had done the right thing and acted with righteous justice, but the reality that I lived in a world of seconders set in. I would be persecuted for my actions no matter how justified. Euphoric release turned back to anger. The only thing I could do is run. I was in no position to be locked in a cage, pregnant as I am still with The First That Shall Change Everything.

    This is what being a Firster in modern America is. None of you knows my lived experiences. These are the Firsting Wars.

    • Gustave Lytton

      I saw a bumper sticker that said “Ku Band”. Radio satellite operator or musician?

      • Brochettaward

        This entire post is gibberish to me.

  2. Ownbestenemy

    Nice article. Drink what you like, who cares what others think and be happy.

  3. Homple

    “It was a hoppy pale ale”, which ushered in a age of domestic cheap-to-brew top fermenting over-hopped swill which was marketed to naifs as “beer”. The small brewery industry is just now showing hints of learning how to make drinkable stuff again.

    • robc

      I was gonna tell the firster to fuck off. But you deserve it more.

      So fuck off.

      • juris imprudent

        Shots fired! Shots fired!

      • Brochettaward

        You mean you were going to tell the Firster how greatly you appreciate the honor of that First, right?

      • Homple

        That won’t change my mind or un-refine my palate.

    • R C Dean

      There’s definitely a place for pale ales and the like. I even order them myself.

      It’s true we did the classic American thing and started competing on who could get the highest bitterness score, with some overhopped swill resulting. But let’s not overgeneralize.

      • Chafed

        +1

        /pale ale fan

    • Gustave Lytton

      Unfortunately, the retards brewing beer have switched to thin wall aluminum cans from glass bottles.

    • Nephilium

      /raises a DIPA

    • KSuellington

      Liberty is an utterly drinkable IPA, the first modern American version. It is in no way over hopped, it really compares more to a slightly hoppy pale ale that the super duper IPAs that are all the rage these days.

      • Chafed

        IPAs are terrible. There, I said it.

      • Stinky Wizzleteats

        Agreed, lager, Pilsner, and stout are the way to go. IPAs taste like diesel fuel.

    • Mojeaux

      But points for using one of my favorite words, “naïf.” You forgot the umlaut, tho.

  4. rhywun

    Reading comments

    Oof – time warp. I was jobless, post one cat dying and just pre the other one, and a few weeks before a trip to the ER.

    Oh, plus all the vid shit. Fun times.

    • Ted S.

      I had put in for two days off work on the 19th and 20th, well before all the lockdown shit.

      Finally started WFH this past Monday, and as I mentioned in another post Dad and I turned over the keys to the old place yesterday.

      • rhywun

        Finally started WFH

        w00t 👍

      • Chafed

        Congratulations on the new place.

  5. R.J.

    I lived through this time. The time of three beer taps. All piss water. Looking back it was so strange.

    • R C Dean

      Same here. I brewed my own for years, mostly because it was the only way to get good beer. As soon as the microbreweries started showing up, I quit. I was in Madison WI at the time, which picked up a some good micros pretty early.

      • R.J.

        I had no real possessions to speak of, or a home so I never got into brewing back then. But I did find Shiner Bock, which was a huge game changer. It tasted so different!

      • Ownbestenemy

        Until you learn where it comes from

      • R.J.

        At the time, Texas.

      • Ownbestenemy

        Bach comes from the bottom of the barrel if I remember right

      • R.J.

        Tastes better than Coors.

      • Ownbestenemy

        No complaints from me. Love me some shiners

      • robc

        People still believe that myth?

  6. Fourscore

    In the early ’70s I was drinking Texas Pride and Buckhorn, a buck a 6 pack. By the end of the ’70s I was dried out and on the wagon. Enough already.

    • DrOtto

      Buckhorn – that was a mainstay in our house.

  7. Toxteth O'Grady

    As a yute I met a Stroh in Colorado, who was very nice. He gave me a Steiff beaver, which our dog then chewed up.

  8. Ownbestenemy

    Wife: Hey lights are flickering and when I walk in a certain part of the trailer they go off

    Me: Weird

    Me also: it’s fixed and never mind the shitty electrical work I did on first trailer

  9. mikey

    My first legal beer was an Anchor Steam. On tap as they claimed it was impossible to bottle. This was before they were bought out. The spaghetti Factory in SF’s North Beach

  10. Zwak , who will swing for the crime, in double time!

    While I like the modern trends in US beer, I do miss the days of walking into a bar and only seeing three things on tap: Bud, Miller, Coors. Easy to make a choice and not worry about being swarmed by the beer snobs. They still stuck to the w(h)ine bar.

  11. Tundra

    I dig this history. I also have fond memories of the Lite commercials.

    I didn’t realize Heileman was as big as they were. This is what always come to mind.

    • rhywun

      LOL, that’s great.

      Never heard of that company or the brand. Everything was more local then, I suppose.

      I still have memories of the wonderful smells of Genny beer brewing in my hometown, wafting across the river as I was biking down Lake Avenue.

      • Gustave Lytton

        Yup. I can remember walking past the Blitz-Weinhard brewery on a trip to Powells.

  12. Michael Malaise

    Expanded, this would be a fantastic book or podcast series.

    Really getting into all of the stories around the industry would be fascinating.

    • R.J.

      Wut

    • Brochettaward

      A Star Is Born is like five years old.

      These people are too stupid to realize that implications are that all that mass media they produced which was consumed by people of all demographics was somehow not inclusive. But this is 2023 and words really don’t mean anything anymore and inclusive doesn’t actually mean what inclusive means.

      • Michael Malaise

        A Star is Born has been made 4 times (1937, 1954, 1976, and 2018)

        And, I’m sorry, but The Adventures of Robin Hood is one of the greatest films ever made.

      • Chafed

        It can only be great when the title role is played by a polyamorous genderqueer of indeterminate racial ancestry. Duh.

      • Brochettaward

        There is a clear pecking order of races. Ambiguously mixed race has nothing on just straight up black. Black is the be all end of all of the oppression Olympics.

      • Brochettaward

        Black is in fact synonymous with diversity and inclusion. Because, again, the actual meaning of words doesn’t matter.

      • Not Adahn

        But Black Cisgays are the White Cisgays of LGBTQ BIPOCs.

    • rhywun

      OFFS!

      On the bright side, I am fairly confident that the great majority of normies will scoff at all the elites sniffing each other’s farts to this crap.

      • Chafed

        You’re right. This will be far less popular than they think. See, for example, the Star Trek series after Enterprise.

    • Gustave Lytton

      Robin Hood with representative casting means only Saxon descended BritsEnglish will play those roles while Norman descendants will fill those roles, right? Because we can’t have other actors or actresses playing whiteface now can we?

      • R.J.

        Lizzo will be an excellent Robin Hood.

      • Chafed

        No way is she giving any food to the poor.

    • Not Adahn

      The filmmakers will begin production this summer and receive mentoring from a team of accomplished producers and directors, including Greg Berlanti (TV’s Arrow, The Flash)

      So they’re admitting Green Arrow is a Robin Hood ripoff?

  13. Gustave Lytton

    In the land of GooniesKindergarten Cop, finally made it to my hotel. Thank goodness for the convenience of mini bottles.

  14. DEG

    He reformulated Anchor Steam

    Anchor Steam is good.

    I read the comments on Part 3. Depressing times.

    • limey

      I ‘member that. Actually not a terrible beer. Not great, but not terrible. YMMV.

      • Not Adahn

        St. Peter’s > Sam Smith’s

  15. Brochettaward

    SEC is looking to increase punishments for fans storming the field.

    We live in a country of pussies where everything and anything is viewed solely through the lens of whether it’s safe (and/or in many instances, there’s potential liability – fuck lawyers). Safety culture was the backbone of covid hysteria.

    Ironically, real threats are often shrugged off. Fucking around with Russia, weakening your military readiness in the process and flashing a bright neon sign saying invade Taiwan to China? Nah, that’s all good.

    • Chafed

      If the SEC isn’t serious about defending our country, then who is?

    • Stinky Wizzleteats

      Just lock everyone in their own padded room and feed them a vitamin enriched gruel. A life that’s too safe is boring.

      • Not Adahn

        A life that’s too exciting is dangerous!

  16. Chafed

    So many of the brewery names are throwbacks to my childhood.

    • Toxteth O'Grady

      Hasenpfeffer Incorporated!

      • Chafed

        Lol.

      • Rat on a train

        Milk and Pepsi is gross.

      • Stinky Wizzleteats

        We’re gonna do it!

  17. Yusef drives a Kia

    Hey hey! Busy working and living,
    Tall Cans!

  18. creech

    My Dad drank something called “Prior,” brewed by Valley Forge Brewing (Adam Scheidt) in Norristown, PA.
    When Pilsner Urquell imports from Czechoslovakia were cut off in 1940, Prior was invented as an American-brewed substitute. It took off after 1945 as a premium beer – sold at places like the Waldorf in NYC – and kept Valley Forge Brewing afloat for a couple decades.

    • limey

      I ‘member them. Apparently their original band was revived in 2022: https://www.discogs.com/artist/35155-Dub-War

      I think I saw them a couple of times warming up for other bands back in the long ago.

      • Sean

        🙂

    • Rat on a train

      According to Don Bozzuffi, president of the league, if a spectator is verbally abusive to an umpire, the person must volunteer to umpire three games or be banned from coming back for up to a year.

      A trained umpire will be with the spectator to help properly call the game.

      So what happens when they verbally abuse the trained umpire?

    • Stinky Wizzleteats

      Verbal abuse of the umpires is part of the game as long as it doesn’t get too crazy.

      • limey

        Is Earl Weaver the benchmark for “too crazy”? What side of the line was he on?

      • Stinky Wizzleteats

        I was thinking the kinds of threats Richard Ramirez would make.

  19. limey

    I like beer in the USA more than in the UK, whatever it is, because it costs half as much or less*.

    *I’m guessing that if you really want to pay crazy money for beer you can go to fancy bars and taprooms in tony towns to have your wallet drained and bladder filled.

  20. limey

    Morning it is. Glibs you are. Good morning you will have.

  21. Shirley Knott

    Mornin’ Sean, limey, and all

    • Gender Traitor

      Good morning, Shirley, limey, Stinky, Roat, and Sean!

      Short work day today, then taking the Big Sweet-But-Dumb Cat in for a check-up and shots.

      • limey

        Mornin’. Best wishes for 🐈

      • Gender Traitor

        Thanks, limey!

      • UnCivilServant

        Morning.

        I hope the cat doesn’t stay mad.

      • Gender Traitor

        Good morning, U!

        Both cats are pretty good at the vet. They just don’t like the car ride to and from.

      • UnCivilServant

        Give the cat a scratch behind the ears from me.

      • Gender Traitor

        Will do. 😸

      • Grosspatzer

        Mornin’, hope the kitty is OK. Short work day is good, I could use one of those, but I need to mind the store while (((they))) celebrate Independence Day. Two day holiday, we could learn something from them.

      • Gender Traitor

        Good morning, ‘patzie! Kitty seems to be OK…except for his weight. 🙄🐱

      • Gender Traitor

        😄👍🏼

    • limey

      Mornin’ Shirl.

  22. Stinky Wizzleteats

    Hmmm, was watching Megyn Kelly on Rumble and according to her Carlson’s still technically under contract (a no compete clause maybe?). We’re not going to be hearing from him for a while, probably after the election at the earliest would be my guess-depends on how they manage the severance negotiations. That old shriveled up Australian fossil is such a worm.

    • limey

      I’d blue sky that as a small win against Big Abortion. It probably isn’t, but it acknowledges that DS people are human beings. The fact that regular Barbie doesn’t look anything like an actual human being (at least not one that hasn’t had a lot of cosmetic procedures) is probably worth mentioning. When is BBW Barbie coming?

      • Grosspatzer

        Mornin’, Limey.

        When is BBW Barbie coming?

        Phrasing?

      • limey

        Apparently she came years ago. I’m not diving any deeper into that (also phrasing?).

      • Stinky Wizzleteats

        Nah, the left over here is all for aborting them into nonexistance too. Mattel will get their pat on the back from the usual suspects before they quietly drop a low volume sales item in a year or two.

      • Fourscore

        I see a collector’s item

  23. Grosspatzer

    Mornin’, reprobates!

    Thanks to one and all for the kind words yesterday. I’ll be in St. Augustine from May 8 – 12, any glibs in that neck o’ the woods?

    Quiet this morning, I think the birds hate the cold as much as I do.

    • Fourscore

      Big Tom Turkey is down to one hen, he still thinks he’s gonna be the one (like Trey in Mojeaux’s series). He parades around as if he’s a teenager with a 3 pack of Trojans in his pocket. 21 degrees this morning, close to a record for this day.