The Greatest Debate

by | Dec 11, 2021 | Beer, Cooking, Food & Drink, Not So Easy Pieces | 200 comments

The greatest debate of our time has nothing to do with guns, abortion, government overreach, foreigners taking our jobs, or ethical ramifications of delegating those questions to politicians.  Which leaves us with more pressing matters.

Is a hot dog a sandwhich?

This is my review of Leinenkugel’s Toasted Bock:

While hot dogs, for better or worse are considered meat and served with a bun, they are not accepted in the sandwich aficionado world.  The reason being the bun itself is a single unit and not a two piece.   Which is problematic if anyone is old enough to remember Subway used to do the u-shaped cut into a single roll, and pulled out by the “sandwich artist”.  This has absolutely nothing to do with anything, other than pointing out the extent of hair-splitting one can go into when discussing such matters. In the end eating enough hot dogs will probably kill you.

This was later derived into other debates involving food products with some sort of filling ensconced within some sort of carbohydrate.  Whether or not a pop tart is a sandwich was postulated.  Which means if a pop tart is a sandwich, surely a calzone, a pierogi, a runza, a beirock, a pasty, or even Beef Wellington must be a sandwich?

Not a pasty, because those come from Cornwall…not Sandwich.

Which then brings us to the nuclear option:

We’re treading softly in the nuclear kitchen:

 

 

NAILED IT

 

 

Leinenkugel’s makes several varieties that are worth seeking out, but they also were among the first to mass produce Shandy so naturally I believe somebody over there needs to be shot.  This isn’t half bad.  When they say “toasted” they mean it.  The malts are roasted to a manner beyond the norm for this style but stops short of the burned coffee-like flavor found in many stouts.  Overall it goes great with a sandwich, or however the hell you want to classify what I just made. Leinenkugel’s Toasted Bock: 3.2/5

About The Author

mexican sharpshooter

mexican sharpshooter

WARNING: Glibertarians.com contains chemicals known to the State of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm. https://youtu.be/qiAyX9q4GIQ?t=2m22s

200 Comments

  1. kinnath

    A pop tart is a pastry.

    • Yusef drives a Kia

      this^

      • Fourscore

        With peanut butter and jelly p-tarts are an open-faced sammich

  2. westernsloper

    While a peanut butter and jelly sandwich adds 33 minutes to your life.

    *cough*bull*cough*shit*cough*

    • ron73440

      Maybe, but as a 50 year old man, I still enjoy PB&J.

      Enough extra crunchy Jif to choke a horse with a thin layer of strawberry preserves and a glass of cold milk. Preferably on toast.

      • Gender Traitor

        I’m trying to cut down on my carbs, so I just scoop a big ol’ spoonful of PB out of the jar and eat it all by itself.

        We usually get creamy but bought a jar of crunchy by accident. It’s divine.

      • westernsloper

        Nothing wrong with that. Eat whatever you want I am not your mom. I am going to make a batch of chili myself. I am trying to let it get above 30 before I light the grill though. Tis fucking cold this morning.

      • Suthenboy

        Chili? On top of sandwiches and beer you have to open that can of worms? Why dont you just toss a pizza while you are at it…

      • Grumbletarian

        You put milk on toast??

      • ron73440

        This place never fails to disappoint.

      • ron73440

        I was thinking impress, how did I type disappoint?

      • Mojeaux

        Works either way.

      • Animal

        Same, only I prefer blackberry preserves. Every cat its own rat, as my Grandpa used to say.

      • Suthenboy

        You misspelled ‘thick’ and ‘blackberry’.

  3. juris imprudent

    You leave out bahn mi and bao? Racist!

    • mexican sharpshooter

      Bao are dumplings and at the risk of being labeled a godless heretic—I have never eaten Bahn Mi.

      • slumbrew

        You are missing out. Bahn Mi ate fantastic.

      • slumbrew

        *are

      • EvilSheldon

        When I lived in MD, there was a tiny little Vietnamese sandwich place up on 355 that was so good… I would go there on Sunday and buy ten Bahn Mi (note – this cost me like thirty bucks) and freeze them for lunch for the week. Gone now, of course. Here in NoVA, I haven’t yet found a local place with quite the same level of swank.

  4. westernsloper

    NAILED IT

    Would. (in before times) That looks like brioche bread which is the only bread worthy of eating imho.

    • mexican sharpshooter

      Its just regular white bread.

      • westernsloper

        You’re dead to me.

      • mexican sharpshooter

        I pay extra for Brioche when I make French toast

      • Name's BEAM. James BEAM.

        Your jib, sir. I like the cut of it.

  5. Sensei

    “ New Study Reveals Eating a Hot Dog Shortens Your Life by 36 Minutes”

    With statistics and quality science like this a COVID research grant is surely in their future.

    • Yusef drives a Kia

      So everyone I ever met is already dead? Fascinating…….

    • ron73440

      I don’t know if they shorten your life, but even as a kid I never liked them.

      A real sausage on a bun is amazing, but hotdogs are like Spam, should only be eaten in a starvation situation.

      • Sensei

        Says the guy who lived in Okinawa.

      • ron73440

        Says the guy who lived in Okinawa.

        If you’re talking about the Spam, my wife learned not to put Spam in my food.

        If we visited the in laws or grandparents, I would eat it then.

      • Yusef drives a Kia

        Nathan’s would beg to differ you heathen!

      • rhywun

        A real sausage on a bun is amazing, but hotdogs are like Spam, should only be eaten in a starvation situation.

        This is the correct observation.

        Hotdogs taste like ass.

      • juris imprudent

        Somehow I don’t think HM is a hot dog afficianado.

      • Ted S.

        Fuck the auto-play video.

      • Sensei

        Sorry didn’t activate in my iPad.

      • rhywun

        +1 auto-play video blocker

      • rhywun

        Seems a little light on details. Like… where the hell are the owners? And why did they abandon the place?

      • Chafed

        And how has it not been auctioned for unpaid property taxes. Something is missing from this story.

      • Not Adahn

        I am so disappointed.

        1. Declare the squatters owners by adverse possession.
        2. Arrest the new owners for non-payment of taxes.
        3. Seize the property as part of the non-payment case.

        NYC has gone to shit since Trump left.

      • R C Dean

        Squatter chick is a cutie.

      • Animal

        Yes, but the rule about sticking it in crazy surely applies.

      • TARDis

        If the utilities are off, they all gotta be pretty rank. Just sayin’.?

      • Fourscore

        ” hotdogs are like Spam”

        After WW2 we got something Spam like in a big OD can, probably about 3-4 lbs, and I’m guessing war surplus. I don’t remember the taste but it was well received at the senior Fourscores. I have Spam in the pantry, just in case. Fried up and make a Spamwich.

      • Mojeaux

        XY likes Spam, but only every so often and he won’t go through a whole can before it goes bad.

      • mexican sharpshooter

        I agree to a point. Hot dogs come in two tiers: something I give to my dogs, or a Kosher dog. There really isn’t much in between.

      • slumbrew

        Doesn’t even have to be kosher – natural casing, all beef hot dogs are the bomb.

      • mexican sharpshooter

        You’re not wrong, but I require the concurrence of a Rabbi.

      • Chafed

        MS gets it.

      • Animal

        On the rare occasion I buy hot dogs, I buy Hebrew National or GTFO. Those things are pretty damn good.

  6. juris imprudent

    That bent bread is the closest thing you can have to a hotdog bun.

  7. Mojeaux

    A hotdog is its own thing. Even if it’s a sausage, it’s still a hotdog.

    A poptart is, yes, a pastry. WTF, a sandwich? WTF? I do not like poptarts, but I did like their toaster scrambles before they started packing them with potatoes.

    Is a gyro a taco or a sandwich? Neither. It’s a gyro. If I could get/make gyro meat and make a gyro like the restaurants do, I’d switch that off with Reubens. I just can’t decide which is better.

    Is an Arby’s Beef’n’Cheddar a sandwich? That’s what they call them, even though they’re on a BUN. But they also call their locations “stores” and there’s not a single aisle you can go down to pick out what you want and take to the register.

    • Yusef drives a Kia

      I miss Arby’s, but driving 30 miles one way for a sandwoich isn’t happening,

    • westernsloper

      If I could get/make gyro meat and make a gyro like the restaurants do

      I am on a lifelong mission to figure that spice blend out. I have tried some recipes I have found but never hit it.

      • Mojeaux

        I have tried some recipes I have found but never hit it.

        Same.

      • tripacer

        I’ve made the Alton Brown gyro meat a few years ago. It was very, very good. A lot of work though. I think that was the one where you put a brick on the meat in the oven.

      • Ownbestenemy

        Yes. Take a skewer and half onion to make your stand and then start layering the meat. Then cook and then shave pieces you need.

    • Gender Traitor

      Is an Arby’s Beef’n’Cheddar a sandwich? That’s what they call them, even though they’re on a BUN.

      Well, it’s not a burger just because it’s on a bun. Buns are especially good for things like chicken salad (my favorite!) because you don’t get soak-through the way you do on most kinds of sliced bread. (Of course, croissants are even better!)

  8. The Late P Brooks

    While a peanut butter and jelly sandwich adds 33 minutes to your life.

    I’m gonna live forever.

    FUCK!

    • Animal

      I’ve heard that every strip of bacon you eat takes a minute off your life. I call bullshit, because if that were true, I would have died in 1804.

  9. The Bearded Hobbit

    Fry up two hot dogs. When hot slice them in half lengthwise. Place the four slices on a slice of bread, add condiments, and cover with another slice of bread.

    Hot dog sandwich.

    • mexican sharpshooter

      You monster.

      • trshmnstr the terrible

        Growing up, we didn’t fry anything up… we nuked it.

        We were also too cheap for hot dog buns, so all of our hot dogs were on off-brand wonderbread.

    • Yusef drives a Kia

      Nailed it!

    • CatchTheCarp

      I like hot dogs – don’t eat them often but I like them. Prefer them cooked on a grill, a griddle works too. Served on a toasted bun.

      Another hot dog controversy: Is putting ketchup on a hot dog blasphemy? Yes.

  10. The Late P Brooks

    What the fuck is wrong with modern “product designers”?

    My new phone (Moto E) is so perfectly smooth and slippery I can’t hold on to the damn thing. I’m going to get some friction tape and wrap it.

    The buttons are conveniently located on the edge so you can inadvertently push them every time you pick the stupid thing up. Why do they think the goddam controls should be hidden?

    • Sensei

      Just buy one of the cheap TPU bumper cases for like $8.

      Less slippery and modest drop protection.

    • EvilSheldon

      Like most modern consumer electronics, it’s not designed for use. It’s designed to be a piece of jewelry that you brag to your friends about having.

      Steve Jobs was a fucking monster. I pray that he’s spending eternity being spit-roasted by demons, for what he did to the field of industrial design.

  11. The Late P Brooks

    I am on a lifelong mission to figure that spice blend out. I have tried some recipes I have found but never hit it.

    The trick is to let the meat age in the open air, preferably at a temperature above 75.

    • hayeksplosives

      It’s also a “meat blend” usually, isn’t it? With some lamb and some beef. That lamb flavor can’t be simulated with spice.

      Steak-ums approximate the texture and thinness.

  12. The Late P Brooks

    Would it really be that hard to put a textured finish on the phone itself?

  13. kinnath

    Thunder and rain yesterday afternoon. Snow over night.

    It the little things that make Iowa worth living in.

    • Yusef drives a Kia

      Heh thunder and rain overnight, now it’s snowing, gotta love Michigan, where the high is the low and the low is the high,

  14. DEG

    The reason being the bun itself is a single unit and not a two piece.

    Hmm… so this means that since I consider a hoagie a sandwich therefore I should also consider a hot dog a sandwich?

    OK. Sure. I don’t eat hot dogs so I don’t really care. I do care a bit about hot dogs: A friend of mine owns a hot dog/burger joint. As long as people are buying from him and he’s making money, that’s good enough for me.

    This isn’t half bad. When they say “toasted” they mean it. The malts are roasted to a manner beyond the norm for this style but stops short of the burned coffee-like flavor found in many stouts. Overall it goes great with a sandwich, or however the hell you want to classify what I just made.

    Sounds tasty.

    • mexican sharpshooter

      A hoagie, is that like a grinder?

      • DEG

        I associate grinders, either rightly or wrongly, with Connecticut, which is like Massachusetts only dirtier and with less culture.

        Hoagies on the other hand are divine, especially those from WaWa.

      • mexican sharpshooter

        So a hoagie is more like a hero then?

      • Yusef drives a Kia

        So are Grinders and Subs and Heros and Hoagie all the same thing? if not why not? I never knew the difference.

      • DEG

        They’re regional terms for the same thing.

      • hayeksplosives

        That’s what I assumed also.

      • Yusef drives a Kia

        I assumed the same thing, but if you need the correct answer, ask the Glibs, you’ll get several

      • MikeS

        I thought grinders had to have taco meat on them. Or is that just a taco grinder?

      • juris imprudent

        Hoagies are a philthadelphia thing. Nothing heroic there.

      • DEG

        I think that would make this game odd.

      • MikeS

        The Taste Atlas agrees with you.

        Grinder is a variety of a submarine sandwich and it is especially popular in New England.

    • Not Adahn

      Hmm… so this means that since I consider a hoagie a sandwich therefore I should also consider a hot dog a sandwich?

      Of course not. all split roll sandwiches (including butter and brie on a baguette) are eaten with the cut held horizontally. Hot dogs are held with the cut held vertically since the bun needs to contain not only the nominal meat, but also the semiliquid toppings.

      • DEG

        When I eat a hoagie, the cut is vertical.

      • DEG

        To add on: The reason is the ones I get are usually overstuffed (like WaWa hoagies with extra meat and cheese). It’s easier to keep everything together.

      • Not Adahn

        So you eat a cold-cut hot dog?

  15. Plisade

    Not mentioned, but relevant, is the Manwich. Looks like a sandwich but is actually a meal.

    And what about this… After a 5 day backpacking trip, a friend ordered a BLT and a double cheeseburger. He then proceeded to put the intact BLT *inside* the double cheeseburger. I call that epic. But is it a sandwich?

    • rhywun

      Sounds like the real manwich to me.

      • Plisade

        A sandwich within a sandwich, the gateway to all understanding.

      • ron73440

        It’s sandwiches all the way down.

    • The Hyperbole

      Your friend is a true American hero.

      • westernsloper

        ^ this is the only time in the history of this site that Hype has been right.

    • Ted S.

      Strong enough for a Manwich, but made for a woman?

    • l0b0t

      I had a grilled cheese sammich, with the bread being 2 egg-in-the-holes/one-eyed-jacks, for breakfast. Is it still a sammich if it requires cutlery?

      • westernsloper

        The best made sandwiches require cutlery. The rest are lame run of the mill losers.

    • mexican sharpshooter

      Yes

    • Suthenboy

      So you had a bacon-double cheese burger.

      MMMM.

  16. Yusef drives a Kia

    Drum roll please, Yusef got a job running an automated car wash, as in all the machinery, inventory, a bit of POS, and be the face of the shop. Amytrpityline is the bomb!

    • DEG

      Excellent!

    • juris imprudent

      Huzzah for gainful employment!

    • ron73440

      That’s great, take care of that back.

      • Yusef drives a Kia

        that’s the cool part, no standing, no heavy lifting, mostly maintenance and water testing etc.

    • Sean

      Yay for Yusef!

    • rhywun

      Heh I just finished watching a King of the Hill where his neighbor buys a carwash and runs it into the ground.

      Don’t do what that guy did.

      • tripacer

        Heh. “Turn-key business”

    • MikeS

      Nice!

    • Grumbletarian

      Congrats! I assume its a very Jetson-ish thing, with you merely having to push a button now and then.

    • mexican sharpshooter

      Congratulations

    • Tundra

      Congrats, brother!

      It’s good to stay busy and, despite everyone here trying to pretend they are the biggest misanthrope, interaction with other people is a good thing.

      Have fun and keep those poor, salt-encrusted cars shiny and intact!!

  17. ron73440

    OT-

    Got my discharge orders and am waiting for my wife.

    I appreciate all the support and seriously am grateful for this little corner of the internet. I haven’t met many of you in person, but the ones I have met have been outstanding.

    Going home now to tend my exploded balls.

    • westernsloper

      Cup away!! Get better!

    • DEG

      It’s good you’re going home. Get well soon!

    • Sean

      Yay for ron!

    • Animal

      Good deal. Best wishes for a speedy and uneventful recovery.

    • Mojeaux

      Take good care of yourself.

    • MikeS

      Going home now to tend my exploded balls.

      I missed something, but I hope your balls get well soon!

    • Yusef drives a Kia

      Get better Ron!

      • R C Dean

        Sometimes people’s balls explode. Natural causes.

    • R.J.

      Boy that sounds unpleasant. Hopes for a speedy recovery.

    • mexican sharpshooter

      Got my discharge orders

      Congratulations! There are several outfits that will hire recently separated Vets, take full advantage!

    • Tundra

      Ice should help.

      Especially if it’s in a cocktail.

  18. Not Adahn

    Sounds like a lot of people are trying for their unrestricted CCL.

  19. Sean

    This whole thing is about carbs and I feel othered.

    Plus you heathens are wrong about sausage. The correct answer is kielbasa.

    • Not Adahn

      My Ossie colleagues claim that currywurst is the best sausage-on-a-bun.

      • DEG

        Currywurst is excellent.

        I enjoyed a lot of it while in Germany and Austria.

      • R.J.

        I have to try that now. Local Bratwurst is good-sounds like I just need to make curry ketchup.

    • ron73440

      Never had kielbasa,my mom would make what she called “spaghetti and kielbasa”, but it was just cut up hot dogs.

      Before you ask, yes it was disgusting and borderline child abuse.

      I just can’t get that image and flavor out of my head when it comes to kielbasa.

      • UnCivilServant

        Hey! I happen to get nostalgic for pasta and hot dogs…

        Sure, it’s not that great, and, okay, it just reminds me of my childhood.

      • Grumbletarian

        I knew a woman from Poland who would make home-made kielbasa of different flavors. Divine!

    • Gender Traitor

      Italian sausage!

      • ron73440

        My wife makes spaghetti with a mix of Italian and hot sausage that’s phenomenal.

      • Yusef drives a Kia

        I use it as part of my chili meat!

    • Mojeaux

      The correct answer is kielbasa

      This is objectively true.

      • UnCivilServant

        Which recipe? over the past month I’ve had a half dozen different sausages all claiming to be kielbasa, no two of which tasted like the others.

        And did Hillshire farms change their recipe it doesn’t taste like it used to.

      • westernsloper

        Hillshire farms kielbasa is just meh to me. I am however a big fan or their take on cajun sausage. I know it is probably not the Louisiana swamp made thing but I like it. It is going in my chili today and goes in all my sort of gumbo style things.

      • UnCivilServant

        It used to be better.

      • rhywun

        The only “kielbasa” I remember eating, and recently, was Hillshire Farms. It was awful. I’d like to try the real thing.

      • Name's BEAM. James BEAM.

        Don’t forget “and intuitively obvious by the light of nature.”

  20. The Late P Brooks

    So a hoagie is more like a hero then?

    “To a New Yorker like you, a Hero is some kind of a weird sandwich.”

  21. The Late P Brooks

    Going home now to tend my exploded balls.

    Excellent. Are you going to stop on the way home and buy some bags of frozen peas?

    • ron73440

      My wife got them for me.

      • Tulip

        Aww.

      • R C Dean

        Twoo wuv.

  22. The Late P Brooks

    my mom would make what she called “spaghetti and kielbasa”, but it was just cut up hot dogs.

    Uh-oh, Spaghetti-os!

    • rhywun

      Ugh… both equally ?

  23. UnCivilServant

    *sigh*

    On one hand I’m glad I resumed my walking. On the other hand I’m annoyed at how the lapse negatively impacted me.

    • Tulip

      It’s depressing how quickly it happens.

    • Yusef drives a Kia

      Just keep going, try not to stop for too long, it’s the only reason I’m attempting a part time job,
      endeavour to perservere,

      • RJD

        yusef gets it. I took a menial job as a clerk/cashier/pizza maker to get off disability. Problem being that the kids used me as unpaid daycare so they could work. I worked my schedule to 2nd shift and limited days to accommodate them. its working out. And I’m happier earning a paycheck than taking a gov provided one

    • limey

      ???

  24. Yusef drives a Kia

    I just heard a Poppy tune on my spotify list, I liked it, Then noticed it was xer, fascinating,

  25. Gender Traitor

    Time for the Army-Navy football game! Go Navy! Beat Army!

    ::checks Navy’s record for this season. Refrains from getting hopes up:: ?

    • Gender Traitor

      …aaaand it took Army all of two minutes to get a TD. ?

    • UnCivilServant

      I can’t take sides in that contest. I have relatives from both the army and navy. And air force, but they’re not playing. Thankfully, no marines. 😛

      • Plisade

        We share Annapolis with the squids.

      • Plisade

        Oh, you mean your relatives :/

    • dbleagle

      Go Army! Beat Navy!

      • Sensei

        Worked with too many Annapolis grads?

      • hayeksplosives

        I’m with you, Dbleagle!!

        Go Army!

    • rhywun

      MLS final is on. NYC vs. Portland *spits*.

    • Gender Traitor

      Navy takes the lead! ? No idea if it will last, but at least for one brief, shining moment…

      • rhywun

        NYC is winning ?
        But it’s very nervy. 4 minutes + stoppage time to go.

    • Tundra

      No need to go past 2.

      Thanks, Q!

  26. Tundra

    I could murder a stromboli right now.

    Even if it isn’t a sandwich.

    Which it clearly is.

  27. Name's BEAM. James BEAM.

    Unmentioned in this otherwise-worthy effort is the Donair (a variant of doner or donner kebab), which looks similar to a Greek gyro but is quite differently flavoured; I see gyros rarely in my neck of the woods, but Donair shops are everywhere:

       Original East Coast Donair recipe

    I could eat these things until I explode (shwarmas, too!).

    • Tundra

      Would.

    • mexican sharpshooter

      Thats a taco.

      • Name's BEAM. James BEAM.

        I’ve had tacos in Mexico, Texas, California, Washington state, Idaho, B.C., Alberta and Saskatchewan.

        Trust me, the Donair tastes nothing like any taco.

      • Name's BEAM. James BEAM.

        I’ve never been to you, either.

      • limey

        Letterkenny!

        To be ffaaaaiirrrr I hope that made it to the comments on KK’s youtube post somewhere.

      • Name's BEAM. James BEAM.

        I haven’t even had a good time in LA, much less tacos.

    • Name's BEAM. James BEAM.

      I’m having a hard time understanding the woman’s reaction; my spousal unit would be all over the contents of that shopping cart.

    • TARDis

      That looks like a well rounded meal to me.

      Us lads are on are own tonight. We’ll see what my son wants to do for dinner after he gets off work. Probably just scrounge since he no doubt filled up on delicious discount Arby’s offerings.

      Oh well, still beats going to a glans viewing party (Nutcracker) with the wife and daughter.

      • rhywun

        How’d you get out of that?

      • TARDis

        It’s simple. Narrowed gaze, followed by, “No.”
        Actually, it’s ‘still’ followed by. It’s been a thing for about 6 years. Mother/daughter thing is fine with me.

    • Sean

      ?

    • TARDis

      Nice. Maybe send him a ladder for Christmas.

  28. commodious spittoon
    • ron73440

      Life is good, got home about 3 hours ago.
      Not nearly as stir crazy now, but I’m not supposed to go to work next week.

  29. This Machine

    SINK NAVY

    Sorry, late to the party. Doing socializing stuff.

    • rhywun

      Portland sunk. ?

      • This Machine

        Aw dammit, hard-fought loss. Congrats to the squids, this year.

  30. commodious spittoon